One of my all-time favorite “girl groups” from the early days of rock ‘n’ roll was The Crystals. They were among the first artists to record for Phil Spector’s Philles Records, and to feature his trademark “Wall Of Sound” production style. Now, to celebrate the 50th anniversary of the 1961 founding of Philles Records, comes a new greatest hits reissue from this fabulous group, titled “Da Doo Ron Ron: The Very Best Of The Crystals.”
The first song I ever heard by The Crystals was not destined to become one of my favorites. It was 1961′s “There’s No Other (Like My Baby),” and it just didn’t grab me. It was a ballad in the soul music vein that I didn’t think was particularly distinguished. But in 1962, their song “Uptown” made me sit up and take notice. This more uptempo piece had a sound that was new to me. It had a flamenco sort of feel to it, with acoustic guitar featured in the brief opening strains, then opening up into a mini-symphony, blending powerful orchestral sounds with castanets, booming percussion and haunting vocals. I became a fan, and started listening for new material on the radio.
Their next release was just plain weird, titled “He Hit Me (And It Felt Like A Kiss),” and written by Carole King(!) It didn’t chart, but the next release did – big time. 1962′s “He’s A Rebel” became The Crystals’ only #1 charting Billboard hit. It was a fantastic song, which I later learned was written by Gene Pitney, that featured the Phil Spector “Wall Of Sound” in all its magnificent glory.
It Was, But It Wasn’t, The Crystals
As it turns out, “He’s A Rebel” wasn’t actually The Crystals. The first three recordings mentioned above featured the original line up, with Barbara Alston on lead vocals, backed by Mary Thomas, Dolores Kenniebrew, Myrna Girard and Patricia Wright. The Crystals were based in New York, while Spector’s Philles Records was in Los Angeles. Depending on whose story you hear, Spector was in such a hurry to release this new song that he couldn’t (or wouldn’t) wait for The Crystals to make travel arrangements. Instead, he brought in another of his groups, The Blossoms, fronted by Darlene Love, and had them record the song, which was then released under The Crystals name. The Darlene Love version of The Crystals had another hit in 1963 with “He’s Sure The Boy I Love,” which peaked at #11 on the U.S. Billboard charts.
The Real Crystals
The “Real” Crystals, as they are sometimes referred to, returned in 1963 to record again for Phil Spector’s Philles Records. This time around, though, Barbara Alston stepped down as lead singer, allowing Dolores “LaLa” Brooks (who had earlier replaced Myrna Girard) to take the spotlight. Alston was known for her shyness, and had always felt somewhat uncomfortable in the lead role, especially on stage.
This version of The Crystals recorded several more songs for the label, among them what might arguably be one of their most cherished, “Da Doo Ron Ron.” I say arguably because, although “He’s A Rebel” was The Crystals’ only #1 chart hit, “Da Doo Ron Ron” reached #3, and has been recorded (covered) by numerous artists, including Bob Dylan, The Rolling Stones, The Beach Boys and others. It remains a staple in rock music, even today. In 2004 Rolling Stone ranked it #114 on its list of the 500 Greatest Songs Of All Time. It’s also worth noting that Cher is listed among the backing vocalists on the recording.
There’s a bit more controversy involved with “Da Doo Ron Ron.” According to Darlene Love, it was actually she and The Blossoms who recorded the song. Phil Spector stripped out her vocal, replacing it with LaLa Brooks’ vocal – possibly due to some contractual misunderstanding. So this song remains a bit of a mystery: Is it The Crystals, The Blossoms, or both?
Among their other hits during this period (1963-64) were “Then He Kissed Me,” (#6 chart hit), “I Wonder,” “Little Boy” and “All Grown Up.”
All of the above, and more (18 tracks in all) are included in the new release/reissue “Da Doo Ron Ron: The Very Best Of The Crystals.” This CD marks the first release of Phil Spector’s Philles Records reissues on the Sony Legacy label. Sony acquired the licensing rights from ABKCO, the label that had previously released Philles reissues.
Is this CD worth adding to your collection?
In my opinion, yes. Even if you own previous releases of The Crystals material, I think you’ll find the sound quality improved here. I did a side-by-side comparison of this Sony Legacy CD to The Crystals’ tracks on the ABKCO boxed set “Back To Mono.” In my opinion, the remastering here is definitely better. These are still the monaural versions of the original hits, but they actually sound more “realistic” in terms of what the Wall Of Sound was really about.
First, it’s important to remember that the Wall Of Sound was not about sonic perfection. It was about BIG and about blending the cacophony of sounds into a UNIT. The effect was actually supposed to be kind of “dirty.” That’s not to say they were meant to sound muddy or distorted, just “big and nasty.”
Second, and for that reason, none of these tracks was originally recorded in stereo. They were recorded to be heard, and sound good, on single-speaker AM car radios, transistor radios, and the simple “record players” of the early 1960′s, none of which was famous for true High Fidelity.
In my opinion, what’s been done with this CD is a remastering job that, while it improves the fidelity of the originals, manages to preserve the sound that was meant to be heard. That is the problem that’s been mentioned in reviews elsewhere concerning previous reissues of this material: They tried too hard to technologically improve the sound, sacrificing the integrity of the original sound Phil Spector worked so hard to create.
As to the issue of the lack of stereo versions, which many collectors have been seeking for decades, I can only repeat that most Philles Records tracks were not in stereo in the first place. Stereo versions of several songs have surfaced over the years, but they were not true stereo. They were binaural (two-track) re-mixes, or “electronically re-channeled for stereo” versions. There have also been re-recordings that have turned up, but these were not the originals, but re-creations which paled in comparison.
I am recommending “Da Doo Ron Ron: The Very Best Of The Crystals” for both serious collectors as well as for fans of The Crystals, as well as both fans and collectors of Phil Spector’s Wall Of Sound. Ultimately, it is your decision, of course. Beauty is in the ear of the listener.
Care Hear Some Samples?
Other releases in the Sony Legacy Phil Spector Philles Records Series:
Be My Baby: The Very Best Of The Ronettes
Sound of Love: The Very Best of Darlene Love
Wall of Sound: The Very Best of Phil Spector 61-66
I would be interested in your take on all of this. Please feel free to leave a comment below!